Episode 12 – Serving as a Nonprofit Board Member

Host: May Harris, Esq.

Guests: David J. O’Brien and Matthew D. Craig

You hear about “founder's syndrome” and somebody so passionate about their cause that they can’t step away and let someone else can grow it and make it even more impactful. Some of the more successful organizations know how to cultivate diverse opinions, know how to let other people run the organization. It's a critical point that distinguishes certain organizations from others.” 

- Matthew D. Craig

In This Episode

Practical insights on what it really means to serve, and leadon a nonprofit board.

Serving on a nonprofit board can be a deeply rewarding experience, but it also comes with serious responsibilities. In this episode, May Harris talks with David J. O’Brien and Matthew D. Craig, coauthors of Building Smart Nonprofits: A Roadmap to Mission Success, about what it takes to be an effective board member. From avoiding short-term thinking to ensuring long-term sustainability, they share real-world lessons and success stories from their decades of experience. Plus, they weigh in on a hot topic: should a young nonprofit host a gala, or is it a potential pitfall?

Key Takeaways

Insightful moments and lessons from the conversation.

  • The role of nonprofit boards in driving mission success and sustainability.

  • Why long-term funding models are critical for organizations serving vulnerable populations.

  • How to match money to mission and tell your story with compelling data.

  • The importance of including operating and overhead expenses in funding proposals.

  • When galas can help a nonprofit—and when they might hurt.

Guest Bio: David J. O'Brien

David J. O’Brien brings 45 years of for-profit leadership experience and deep nonprofit board expertise to his work with organizations around the globe. He has served as Board Chair, Committee Chair, and Director/Trustee of nonprofits in education, global health, social services, and the arts. When he’s not engaged in the nonprofit community, David enjoys sailing, painting, cooking, and traveling with his wife, Dr. Paula Cordeiro, to support NGOs in Africa and Central/South America.

Guest Bio: Matthew D. Craig

Matthew D. Craig is vice president and senior relationship manager with JPMorgan Chase, specializing in services for governments and nonprofits. With over two decades in the financial sector, Matt has held roles in credit underwriting, commercial banking, and private wealth management. A lifelong volunteer and advocate, Matt loves teaching, traveling, and spending time with his wife Courtney and their twins in Escondido, California.

Subscribe Here:

Stay Connected with Nonprofit Counsel
Subscribe to our podcast for expert conversations, and join our newsletter for insights, tools, and updates designed for nonprofit leaders like you.

Resources

Connect With Us

© Nonprofit Counsel 2025 All Rights Reserved.

Level Up Your Nonprofit – Join Today!